Love the fuel door Mod. Great idea 
When I turn the key my lid doesn't pop up,it stays flat with the surface of the cover,I cannot lift it up with my fingernail,I must use something like a toothpick or a key which is a bit risky for the chrome finish of the lid.I'm having a hard time understanding the need/purpose for the fuel door mod. I turn the key, the lid pops up, and I gently lift the lid up without need for any external force or tools. What does the rubber thing do for you that isn't happening without it?
Richmonder
The reason of the lid not popping up is two holes that are missing a rubber buttons,I don't know how to name them.Strange. I wonder why it wasn't working as it should. You shouldn't have to do that. Maybe take it to Honda and see if they can give you some idea. But, you've fixed it, so maybe not worry about it. I hope that higher pressure from the rubber doesn't push out a dent in the cover at some point.
Richmonder